SJM changes
Pick any two versions below to diff them.
- Price
- $131.71 → $133.68(+1.5%)
- Discount category
- Pricey → Far above intrinsic value
- Next earnings is estimate
- Yes → No
- Thesis
- The price of Smucker depends on whether its earnings can grow again after the cost of the Hostess purchase and a period of very high coffee costs. Adjusted EPS fell 10% to $9.15 in fiscal 2026, and Smucker recorded impairment charges of $961.7 million on the goodwill of Sweet Baked Snacks and the Hostess trademark. In fiscal 2027 adjusted EPS guidance is $10.50 to $11.00, but this includes a net benefit of about $0.60 from tariff refunds that will not repeat, and net sales are expected to fall 1% to 2% as coffee prices come down. Debt was about $6.8 billion at July 31, 2026, so Smucker uses much of its cash to repay debt. For the price to hold or rise, three things must be true. Coffee profit must stay high as Smucker lowers its prices with lower costs. Uncrustables must keep growing and Sweet Baked Snacks must stop its decline. Free cash flow of about $1.1 billion a year must keep reducing debt. The Q2 fiscal 2027 removed: report, expected in late added: report on November removed: 2026, added: 24, 2026 and the fiscal 2028 outlook in June 2027 are the next tests.
- Checkpoints
- Nov 24, removed: 2026 (estimate): added: 2026: Q2 fiscal 2027 results. Pending. Watch: Smucker keeps or raises its fiscal 2027 adjusted EPS guidance of $10.50 to $11.00, and this passes; a lower range fails. Jun 2027 (estimate): Fiscal 2027 results and fiscal 2028 outlook. Pending. Watch: Fiscal 2028 adjusted EPS guidance is at or above $10.15 at the midpoint, the fiscal 2027 figure without the tariff refunds, and this passes; a lower midpoint fails.